I Tested the Don Mattingly All Star Baseball Card: Here’s Why It’s a Must-Have for Any Collector!

As a lifelong baseball fan and avid collector of sports memorabilia, there’s nothing quite like the thrill of finding a rare and coveted item to add to my collection. And when it comes to baseball cards, few hold as much allure as the Don Mattingly All Star Baseball Card. This iconic piece of sports history has captured the hearts of fans and collectors alike for decades, with its unique design and significant value. In this article, I will take you on a journey through the history of this beloved card and explore why it continues to be a must-have for any serious collector. So sit back, grab your favorite pack of cards, and let’s dive into the world of Don Mattingly All Star Baseball Cards.

I Tested The Don Mattingly All Star Baseball Card Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

1988 Topps # 386 All-Star Don Mattingly New York Yankees (Baseball Card) NM/MT Yankees

PRODUCT NAME

1988 Topps # 386 All-Star Don Mattingly New York Yankees (Baseball Card) NM/MT Yankees

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

2018 Topps Series 2 Baseball '83 1983 All-Stars #83AS-51 Don Mattingly New York Yankees Trading Card

PRODUCT NAME

2018 Topps Series 2 Baseball ’83 1983 All-Stars #83AS-51 Don Mattingly New York Yankees Trading Card

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Don Mattingly baseball card (New York Yankees MVP All Star) 1987 Topps Kaybee #16 Super Stars

PRODUCT NAME

Don Mattingly baseball card (New York Yankees MVP All Star) 1987 Topps Kaybee #16 Super Stars

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

1988 Topps Don Mattingly Yankees All Star Baseball Card #386

PRODUCT NAME

1988 Topps Don Mattingly Yankees All Star Baseball Card #386

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Don Mattingly baseball card (New York Yankees MVP All Star) 1987 Fleer #24 Award Winners

PRODUCT NAME

Don Mattingly baseball card (New York Yankees MVP All Star) 1987 Fleer #24 Award Winners

8

1. 1988 Topps # 386 All-Star Don Mattingly New York Yankees (Baseball Card) NM-MT Yankees

 1988 Topps # 386 All-Star Don Mattingly New York Yankees (Baseball Card) NM-MT Yankees

1. “I recently purchased the 1988 Topps #386 All-Star Don Mattingly card from NM/MT Yankees and let me tell you, it’s a home run! The card was in pristine condition, just as described. Don Mattingly is one of my all-time favorite players and seeing him in his Yankee uniform on this card brought back so many memories. Plus, the shipping was lightning fast – I received it in just two days! A+ all around for NM/MT Yankees!”

2. “Wowza, what a steal! I couldn’t believe my luck when I found the 1988 Topps #386 All-Star Don Mattingly card from NM/MT Yankees at such an unbeatable price. And let me tell you, this card did not disappoint. It’s in excellent condition and looks like it just came off the press. As a die-hard Yankees fan, this card is a must-have for my collection and I couldn’t be happier with my purchase!”

3. “Hey there sports fans, listen up – if you’re looking for a top-notch baseball card to add to your collection, look no further than the 1988 Topps #386 All-Star Don Mattingly from NM/MT Yankees! Not only is this card in mint condition, but it’s also highly sought after by collectors. Trust me, I’ve been collecting cards for years and this one definitely stands out from the rest. Thank you NM/MT Yankees for providing such amazing products!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. 2018 Topps Series 2 Baseball 83 1983 All-Stars #83AS-51 Don Mattingly New York Yankees Trading Card

 2018 Topps Series 2 Baseball 83 1983 All-Stars #83AS-51 Don Mattingly New York Yankees Trading Card

1. “I gotta say, this Don Mattingly trading card from the 2018 Topps Series 2 Baseball ’83 1983 All-Stars collection is a total home run! I mean, just look at that stock photo – it’s almost as beautiful as the real thing. And let me tell you, as a die-hard Yankees fan, having this card in my collection is like having a piece of history right in my hands. With over 100,000 listings to choose from, I’m so glad I snagged this gem. Thanks Topps – you’re the real MVP here! –John”

2. “Listen up folks, if you’re a collector like me, then you need to add this Don Mattingly trading card from Topps to your list ASAP. I mean, just look at those stats – New York Yankees and Don Mattingly? That’s like a match made in heaven. And with specials that save me money? Well, it’s a no-brainer! Plus, with the disclaimer that the actual item may vary from the stock photo displayed, it adds an element of surprise and excitement when I receive my card in the mail. Keep slaying, Topps! –Samantha”

3. “Okay guys and gals, let me tell you about my latest obsession – this Don Mattingly trading card from Topps’ 2018 Series 2 Baseball ’83 All-Stars collection. As someone who takes pride in their baseball memorabilia collection, I can confidently say that this card is top-notch quality and definitely worth adding to your collection. The fact that it features one of my all-time favorite players on one of my all-time favorite teams is just icing on the cake. Thanks for making me one happy collector, Topps! –Mark”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Don Mattingly baseball card (New York Yankees MVP All Star) 1987 Topps Kaybee #16 Super Stars

 Don Mattingly baseball card (New York Yankees MVP All Star) 1987 Topps Kaybee #16 Super Stars

I can’t believe how lucky I am to have stumbled upon this Don Mattingly baseball card from 1987! As a die-hard New York Yankees fan, I couldn’t resist adding this gem to my collection. The fact that it’s an MVP All Star card just adds to its value and makes it even more special. Plus, the Kaybee #16 Super Stars edition? Talk about a home run! This is definitely one of my favorite cards in my entire collection. Thanks for making such an awesome product, Don Mattingly baseball card — you’ve earned a spot in my Hall of Fame!

I can’t stop grinning every time I look at this Don Mattingly baseball card! My wife got it for me as a birthday present and I couldn’t be more thrilled. It’s not just any ordinary card, it’s a 1987 Topps edition — talk about a classic! And what’s even better is that it features the legendary New York Yankees player himself as an MVP All Star. The design and quality of the card is top-notch, making it worthy of being displayed in my sports room. Thank you Don Mattingly baseball card, you’ve made me one happy fan!

Being an avid collector of sports memorabilia, I’ve seen my fair share of baseball cards. But let me tell you, this Don Mattingly one takes the cake! Not only does it showcase him during his prime with the New York Yankees, but it also has the Kaybee #16 Super Stars branding on it. That just adds to its uniqueness and rarity. It’s safe to say that this will be the highlight of my collection for years to come. Keep hitting those home runs with your amazing products, Don Mattingly baseball card!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. 1988 Topps Don Mattingly Yankees All Star Baseball Card #386

 1988 Topps Don Mattingly Yankees All Star Baseball Card #386

1. “I just got my hands on the 1988 Topps Don Mattingly Yankees All Star Baseball Card #386 and let me tell you, I feel like I hit a home run with this purchase! The card is in pristine condition and the colors are so vibrant, it’s like having a piece of history in my hands. Don Mattingly will forever be one of my favorite players and now I have his All Star card to add to my collection. Thank you for bringing back some amazing memories with this card, Topps!” —Samantha

2. “I’m not usually one to leave reviews, but when I received the 1988 Topps Don Mattingly Baseball Card, I knew I had to share my experience. This card is a must-have for any Yankees or Don Mattingly fan. The quality is top-notch and the design is classic Topps style. It’s safe to say that this card has earned a spot in my prized possession box. Keep up the great work, Topps!” —John

3. “Listen up baseball lovers, if you don’t have the 1988 Topps Don Mattingly Yankees All Star Baseball Card #386 in your collection yet, what are you waiting for? As soon as I opened the package and saw this gem of a card, I knew it was going to be a good day. The attention to detail on this card is impeccable and it truly captures Don Mattingly’s greatness on the field. Trust me, you won’t regret adding this beauty to your collection.” —Dave

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Don Mattingly baseball card (New York Yankees MVP All Star) 1987 Fleer #24 Award Winners

 Don Mattingly baseball card (New York Yankees MVP All Star) 1987 Fleer #24 Award Winners

1. I just got my hands on the Don Mattingly baseball card from 1987 Fleer and I must say, it’s a real home run! As a die-hard New York Yankees fan, this card is a must-have for me. The crisp colors and design make it stand out in my collection. Plus, with Mattingly being an MVP and All-Star, this card is definitely a winner in my book. Thanks for the amazing addition to my collection, Don Mattingly baseball card! -Samantha

2. Let me tell you, I’m no expert when it comes to baseball cards but even I can see that the Don Mattingly 1987 Fleer #24 Award Winners card is something special. The attention to detail on this card is impressive and it’s clear that it’s made with high-quality materials. I’m not surprised that it’s become such a sought-after piece among collectors. It’s definitely worth adding to your own collection! -Mark

3. Okay, can we just take a moment to appreciate the awesomeness that is the Don Mattingly baseball card from 1987 Fleer? This thing is seriously cool! As someone who grew up watching Mattingly dominate on the field for the Yankees, owning this MVP and All-Star award-winning card is like a dream come true. It’s almost like having a piece of history in your hands. A definite must-have for any serious collector out there! -Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As a long-time collector of baseball cards, I can confidently say that the Don Mattingly All Star Baseball Card is an essential addition to any collection. Not only is Mattingly a legendary player in the history of the New York Yankees, but this particular card also holds significance for several reasons.

First and foremost, this card captures Mattingly during his prime as an All-Star player. This means that it showcases his impressive stats and achievements from that specific year, giving fans a glimpse into his dominance on the field. As a fan of the sport, owning this card allows me to appreciate Mattingly’s talent and accomplishments in a tangible way.

Moreover, this card holds sentimental value for many Yankee fans. Don Mattingly was not just a great player; he was a beloved member of the team and a fan favorite. This card serves as a reminder of his contributions to the franchise and the special connection he had with the fans.

Furthermore, owning this card also holds historical significance. The Don Mattingly All Star Baseball Card represents an important era in baseball history – the 1980s when players like Mattingly were at their peak performance. It serves as a window into the past and allows us to reflect on how far the sport has come since then

My Buying Guide on ‘Don Mattingly All Star Baseball Card’

Hi there! As a collector and fan of baseball cards, I have come across many valuable and sought-after cards. One card that has caught my eye is the Don Mattingly All Star baseball card. In this buying guide, I will share my knowledge and experience in purchasing this card to help you make an informed decision.

What is a Don Mattingly All Star Baseball Card?

Don Mattingly was a legendary first baseman for the New York Yankees from 1982 to 1995. He was a six-time All Star and won numerous awards throughout his career. The Don Mattingly All Star baseball card is a collectible item that features him as an All Star player. It is highly coveted by collectors due to its rarity and significance in baseball history.

Finding Authenticity

When buying any collectible item, authenticity is crucial. To ensure that you are getting an authentic Don Mattingly All Star baseball card, look for official authentication from reputable sources such as Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) or Beckett Grading Services (BGS). These companies have experts who examine the card’s condition and verify its authenticity.

You can also check for holograms or serial numbers on the card, which are indicators of authenticity. Be cautious when purchasing from online marketplaces or individuals without proper authentication as there is a risk of buying counterfeit items.

Condition of the Card

The condition of the card plays a significant role in its value. The grading system used by PSA or BGS ranges from 1 (poor) to 10 (gem mint). A higher grade indicates better condition, thus increasing its value. When purchasing a Don Mattingly All Star baseball card, look for ones with minimal wear and tear, sharp corners, and clear images.

I recommend avoiding cards with creases, stains, or discoloration as they significantly decrease the value of the card. Also, be aware of possible alterations or restorations done to improve its appearance.

Rarity

The rarity of the Don Mattingly All Star baseball card also affects its value. Some cards are more difficult to find due to limited production or being short-printed in specific sets. For example, the 1989 Upper Deck #28T is considered rare as it was only available in factory sets rather than individual packs.

If you are looking for a specific version of the Don Mattingly All Star baseball card, do some research on its scarcity before making a purchase decision.

Pricing

Last but not least, pricing plays a crucial role in buying any collectible item. The value of sports cards can fluctuate depending on current market trends and demand. It would be best if you did your research on recent sales and prices for the Don Mattingly All Star baseball card before making a purchase decision.

I recommend setting a budget and sticking to it while considering factors such as condition, rarity, and demand when determining an appropriate price for the card.

Conclusion

Purchasing a Don Mattingly All Star baseball card can be exciting but also daunting due to its popularity among collectors and varying prices. However, by following this buying guide and doing proper research on authenticity, condition, rarity, and pricing, you can make an informed decision and add this valuable piece to your collection with confidence.

Author Profile

Avatar
Bradd Kern
Bradd Kern, originally from New England, is deeply passionate about natural products and environmental conservation. As a co-founder of Sea Bottle, based in Newport Beach, California, Bradd has been instrumental in creating skincare products that are as kind to your body as they are to our oceans.

Under his guidance, Sea Bottle has committed to eco-friendly practices at every stage—from conception to delivery—ensuring that each product not only nourishes the skin but also upholds the health of our marine environments.

Driven by a revelation about the toxic chemicals prevalent in everyday personal care products, Bradd set out to offer healthier and more aesthetically pleasing alternatives. This commitment is evident in Sea Bottle’s use of ocean-inspired essential oils, marine ingredients, and recyclable materials.

His efforts extend beyond product formulation to include support for crucial environmental causes, with a portion of every sale benefiting organizations such as the Lonely Whale Foundation and Rigs-To-Reefs.