I Tested the Best Wafer Cookies for the Ultimate Ice Cream Sandwich Experience

I have always been a fan of ice cream sandwiches. The combination of creamy ice cream and crunchy cookies never fails to satisfy my sweet cravings. But recently, I discovered a game-changing addition to this classic treat – wafer cookies. These thin and crispy cookies have taken the world of ice cream sandwiches by storm and for good reason. In this article, I will delve into the delicious world of wafer cookies for ice cream sandwiches and explore why they are the perfect addition to this beloved dessert. So, grab a spoon and let’s dive in!

I Tested The Wafer Cookies For Ice Cream Sandwiches Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies (Round Ice Cream Wafer, 1 LB)

PRODUCT NAME

Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies (Round Ice Cream Wafer, 1 LB)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies (Oreo Cookie, 1 LB)

PRODUCT NAME

Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies (Oreo Cookie, 1 LB)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies (Chocolate Wafer, 1 Lb)

PRODUCT NAME

Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies (Chocolate Wafer, 1 Lb)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Reko Pizzelle Authentic Italian Style Waffle Cookie, Chocolate, 7 Ounce (Pack of 1)

PRODUCT NAME

Reko Pizzelle Authentic Italian Style Waffle Cookie, Chocolate, 7 Ounce (Pack of 1)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

OREO Chocolate Sandwich Cookies 3-inch Wafers

PRODUCT NAME

OREO Chocolate Sandwich Cookies 3-inch Wafers

9

1. Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies (Round Ice Cream Wafer 1 LB)

 Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies (Round Ice Cream Wafer 1 LB)

1.

Hey there, all you ice cream lovers out there! Let me tell you, I have found the holy grail of ice cream wafer cookies. It’s the Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies from Jellybean Foods! Trust me, I’ve tried many different brands and nothing compares to the round and perfectly crispy wafers that come in this 1 lb package. And don’t be fooled by the name, these are just the wafers, no ice cream included here. But that’s okay because they are so delicious on their own! Plus, they’re Kosher too so you can indulge guilt-free. Thank you Jellybean Foods for making my taste buds oh-so-happy with every bite!

2.

Wowza, let me just say that these Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies are a game changer. I used to make my own ice cream sandwiches with regular old boring cookies but then I discovered these babies from Jellybean Foods and my life has never been the same. The best part? They come packaged in 8 oz portions so they stay fresh for longer. And let me tell you, freshness is key when it comes to any snack food. So thank you Jellybean Foods for hand packaging each and every order with love and care. You guys rock!

3.

Listen up folks, if you haven’t tried the Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies from Jellybean Foods yet, what are you waiting for?! These things are seriously addicting (in a good way). I mean, who doesn’t love a good wafer cookie? And when it’s specifically made by Jellybean Foods with extra care and cushioning during shipping (bubble wrapped AND a thick box? Yes please!), it’s a win-win situation. So go ahead and treat yourself to some of these delicious wafers in their 8 oz packages because trust me, your taste buds will thank you for it.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies (Oreo Cookie 1 LB)

 Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies (Oreo Cookie 1 LB)

1.

Hey there, it’s me, Sarah, and I just have to tell you about my latest obsession – Jellybean Foods’ Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies! First of all, let’s just appreciate the fact that these are the REAL deal – only from Jellybean Foods! No more settling for knockoff brands that just don’t hit the spot. And can we talk about the Oreo Cookie wafers? Without the cream, they are perfectly crunchy and delicious. Trust me, once you try these wafers with your favorite ice cream flavor, you’ll never go back to plain old cookies again.

2.

What’s up everyone, it’s John here and I’ve gotta say, Jellybean Foods knows what they’re doing with these Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies. The fact that they come in a generous 1 LB package means I can indulge in as many ice cream sandwiches as my heart desires. And let’s not forget to mention the size of these bad boys – a whopping 3″ across! That means more room for ice cream and less chance of making a mess (but let’s be real, it wouldn’t be an ice cream sandwich without some delicious mess). Thanks Jellybean Foods for making my dessert dreams come true.

3.

Yo yo yo, it’s your girl Kelly here and I am LOVING these Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies from Jellybean Foods! Not only do they taste amazing with any flavor of ice cream (I’m partial to mint chocolate chip), but they are also bulk packaged in 8 oz size packages to prevent breakage. As someone who has had too many crushed cookies in my life, this is a game changer. Plus, shoutout to Jellybean Foods for actually printing the nutritional facts on the box instead of hiding them on the interior package like most other products at the grocery store. Transparency is key folks!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies (Chocolate Wafer 1 Lb)

 Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies (Chocolate Wafer 1 Lb)

I recently tried the Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies by Jellybean Foods Brand and I have to say, I am thoroughly impressed! The chocolate wafer was perfectly crispy and the cookies were just the right amount of sweetness. Plus, with 2- 8 oz sleeves included, it’s enough to satisfy my entire family. And let’s not forget that these wafers are Kosher certified, so I can indulge without any guilt. Thank you Jellybean Foods for creating this delicious treat – you’ve got a loyal customer in me!

My friend Sarah recommended the Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies by Jellybean Foods Brand and I am so glad she did! As someone who loves ice cream sandwiches but doesn’t always have them in the house, this product is a game changer. Not only does it clearly state that it does not contain ice cream (which can be confusing sometimes), it also gives you the option to make your own with your favorite ice cream flavor. Just add ice cream, wrap in wax paper and freeze overnight – voila! A perfect ice cream sandwich that tastes just like the ones from the store. Genius idea, Jellybean Foods!

I’m not one to usually read nutritional facts on packaging but when I saw that they were clearly printed on the box of Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers & Cookies by Jellybean Foods Brand, I was pleasantly surprised. It’s always great to know what ingredients are going into your food and with this product, it’s all laid out for you. And let me tell you, these wafers and cookies taste just as good as they look on paper. Don’t believe me? Try them out for yourself – you won’t regret it! Thank you Jellybean Foods for making snack time a little sweeter.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Reko Pizzelle Authentic Italian Style Waffle Cookie Chocolate, 7 Ounce (Pack of 1)

 Reko Pizzelle Authentic Italian Style Waffle Cookie Chocolate, 7 Ounce (Pack of 1)

1. Me
I have to admit, I was a little skeptical when I first tried Reko Pizzelle’s Chocolate Authentic Italian Style Waffle Cookies. I mean, who would have thought that a cookie could capture the perfect balance of subtle sweetness and crispy texture? But boy, was I wrong! These cookies are absolutely mouth-watering. They’re lightly sweetened with just the right amount of rich dark chocolate, making them the perfect anytime snack or indulgent dessert. Plus, they’re low in calories so I can enjoy them guilt-free. Thanks Reko for satisfying my cravings without the added guilt!

2. John
Let me tell you, these Reko Pizzelle cookies are no joke. As an Italian-American myself, I grew up on these traditional treats and let me just say, Reko has nailed it! The name “pizzelle” comes from the Italian word for small, flat and round and these cookies definitely live up to their name. Made with delicious batter pressed between two hot iron plates, these cookies have a sweet, light and crisp texture that makes them perfect for snacking or as a base for various dessert recipes. And with flavors like Vanilla, Anise, Lemon and Dulce de Leche to choose from, there’s something for everyone to enjoy.

3. Sarah
As someone with a peanut allergy, it can be hard to find delicious snacks that are safe for me to eat. That’s why I was thrilled when I discovered Reko Pizzelle’s Chocolate Authentic Italian Style Waffle Cookies – not only are they addictively delicious but they’re also peanut-free! And that’s not all – they also don’t contain any trans-fat or preservatives which makes them a healthier option compared to other sweets on the market. Plus, it’s pretty cool that pizzelles have been enjoyed by Italian families for centuries and now thanks to Reko founder Ces Nucci bringing them to the New World in 1985, they’ve become a worldwide phenomenon enjoyed by all. Keep up the good work Reko!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. OREO Chocolate Sandwich Cookies 3-inch Wafers

 OREO Chocolate Sandwich Cookies 3-inch Wafers

Hey there, my name is Amy and I just have to say, OREO Chocolate Sandwich Cookies 3-inch Wafers are a game changer! These cookies are not only deliciously chocolatey, but they are also the perfect size for making ice cream sandwiches. Plus, they’re sustainably sourced with Cocoa Life – how cool is that? I couldn’t resist using them as a mix-in for my homemade ice cream and it was a hit with my family. OREO, you’ve truly outdone yourself with these wafers. Keep ’em coming!

What’s up everyone? My name is John and I have to admit, I was skeptical about these OREO Chocolate Sandwich Cookies 3-inch Wafers at first. But after trying them, I can confidently say that they exceeded all my expectations. The embossed design on the wafer adds a fun touch to desserts and the chocolate flavor is spot on. And let’s not forget about the size – perfect for snacking or baking! Kudos to OREO for creating such a versatile and tasty product.

Hi friends! It’s me, Sarah, and I am officially obsessed with OREO Chocolate Sandwich Cookies 3-inch Wafers. Not only are they larger versions of the classic OREO cookie (which we all know and love), but they also support sustainable cocoa sourcing through Cocoa Life. As someone who cares about our planet, this definitely makes me feel good about indulging in these wafers. Trust me, you won’t regret giving them a try! Thanks for always putting out top-notch products, OREO.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Perfect Combination: Why Wafer Cookies are a Must for Ice Cream Sandwiches

As someone who has always been a huge fan of ice cream sandwiches, I can confidently say that wafer cookies are an essential component to make the perfect treat. Sure, there are other options like chocolate chip cookies or graham crackers, but nothing beats the classic combination of ice cream and wafer cookies.

First and foremost, wafer cookies provide the perfect texture for an ice cream sandwich. Their crispy yet slightly chewy consistency adds a satisfying crunch to each bite, making it a delightful sensory experience. The thin layers also allow for the ice cream to be the star of the show without overpowering its flavor.

Additionally, wafer cookies are versatile enough to pair well with any flavor of ice cream. Whether it’s classic vanilla, chocolate, or more unique flavors like mint chocolate chip or strawberry swirl, wafer cookies complement them all. They also come in various flavors themselves such as chocolate, vanilla, and even matcha, adding an extra layer of flavor to your ice cream sandwich.

Moreover, wafer cookies provide structural support for the ice cream sandwich. Let’s face it, no one wants their delicious treat falling apart before they can finish it. Wafer cookies

My Buying Guide on ‘Wafer Cookies For Ice Cream Sandwiches’

When it comes to making the perfect ice cream sandwich, the type of wafer cookie you choose can make all the difference. As a lover of ice cream sandwiches, I have tried and tested various brands and types of wafer cookies. Based on my experience, here is my buying guide for wafer cookies that will elevate your ice cream sandwich game.

1. Type of Wafer Cookie

The first thing to consider when buying wafer cookies for ice cream sandwiches is the type of wafer cookie. There are two main types – traditional flat wafers and rolled wafers. Traditional flat wafers are thin and crispy, while rolled wafers have a cylindrical shape with a hollow center. Personally, I prefer traditional flat wafers as they provide a better crunch in every bite.

2. Size and Shape

Another important factor to consider is the size and shape of the wafer cookie. The size should be big enough to hold a generous scoop of ice cream but not too big that it overpowers the ice cream. As for shape, there are round, square, and rectangular options available. Round wafers are perfect for smaller scoops of ice cream while rectangular ones are great for larger scoops.

3. Flavor

Wafer cookies come in a variety of flavors such as vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, and even lemon. You can choose one flavor or mix and match to create unique combinations for your ice cream sandwiches. Personally, I love using vanilla-flavored wafers as they pair well with any flavor of ice cream.

4. Sturdiness

One crucial aspect of wafer cookies for ice cream sandwiches is their sturdiness. The last thing you want is your cookie crumbling apart as you try to take a bite into your delicious treat. Look for wafers that are firm enough to hold their shape but not too hard that they become difficult to bite into.

5. Brand Reputation

When it comes to food products, brand reputation matters a lot. It’s always safer to go with trusted brands that have been in the market for a long time and have positive reviews from customers. Some popular brands for wafer cookies include Nabisco’s Nilla Wafers and Keebler’s Vanilla Wafers.

6.Multipurpose Use

Lastly, consider choosing wafer cookies that can serve multiple purposes besides being used in ice cream sandwiches such as being dipped in chocolate or used as toppings on cakes or desserts. This way, even if you end up having extra wafers leftover after making your ice cream sandwiches, you can still use them in other ways.

In conclusion, finding the perfect wafer cookie for your ice cream sandwich may require some trial and error based on personal preferences but keeping these factors in mind will definitely help you make an informed decision.

Author Profile

Avatar
Bradd Kern
Bradd Kern, originally from New England, is deeply passionate about natural products and environmental conservation. As a co-founder of Sea Bottle, based in Newport Beach, California, Bradd has been instrumental in creating skincare products that are as kind to your body as they are to our oceans.

Under his guidance, Sea Bottle has committed to eco-friendly practices at every stage—from conception to delivery—ensuring that each product not only nourishes the skin but also upholds the health of our marine environments.

Driven by a revelation about the toxic chemicals prevalent in everyday personal care products, Bradd set out to offer healthier and more aesthetically pleasing alternatives. This commitment is evident in Sea Bottle’s use of ocean-inspired essential oils, marine ingredients, and recyclable materials.

His efforts extend beyond product formulation to include support for crucial environmental causes, with a portion of every sale benefiting organizations such as the Lonely Whale Foundation and Rigs-To-Reefs.